R. Mcgraw et Rj. Weber, HYDRATES IN BINARY SULFURIC ACID-WATER VAPOR - COMPARISON OF CIMS MEASUREMENTS WITH THE LIQUID-DROP MODEL, Geophysical research letters, 25(16), 1998, pp. 3143-3146
We report calculations of the distribution of sulfuric acid-water hydr
ates under atmospheric conditions using the liquid-drop hydrate model.
The model-computed total acid concentrations (free acid plus hydrated
acid) are compared with chemical ionization mass spectrometer (CIMS)
measurements of total sulfuric acid vapor over solutions of varying co
ncentration [Marti et al., 1997] Results from this first direct compar
ison with experimental measurement suggest that the liquid-drop model
overestimates the extent of hydrate formation. We explore the conseque
nces of this overestimation on binary sulfuric acid-water nucleation r
ates, and on higher-order multicomponent nucleation rates involving th
ese and additional trace species in the atmosphere. In particular, it
is found that overestimation of hydrate formation by the model can res
ult in substantial underprediction of sulfuric acid-water nucleation r
ates.