Research on nonpoint pollution control instruments has focused primari
ly on incentives applied either to production inputs that affect nonpo
int pollution, or to ambient pollution concentrations. Both approaches
may in theory yield an efficient solution. However, input-based incen
tives will generally have to be second-best to make implementation pra
ctical. Design issues include which inputs to monitor and the rates to
apply to them. The limited research indicates that second-best, input
-based incentives can be effective in adjusting input use in environme
ntally desirable ways. Alternatively, ambient-based incentives have th
eoretical appeal because efficient policy design appears to be less co
mplex than for input-based incentives. These incentives have no track
record nor close analogues that demonstrate potential effectiveness, h
owever. Research on how households and firms might react in response t
o ambient-based incentives is needed before these instruments can be s
eriously considered.