J. Elen et J. Lowyck, STUDENTS VIEWS ON THE EFFICIENCY OF INSTRUCTION - AN EXPLORATORY SURVEY OF THE INSTRUCTIONAL METACOGNITIVE KNOWLEDGE OF UNIVERSITY FRESHMEN, Higher education, 36(2), 1998, pp. 231-252
Students have conceptions about the relationship between instructional
interventions and learning or, in other words, students have 'instruc
tional metacognitive knowledge'. In this study, the efficiency of inst
ructional interventions has been investigated as a specific object of
students' instructional metacognitive knowledge. By means of a survey,
conceptions about the efficiency of various instructional interventio
ns of 488 freshmen in educational sciences and psychology have been in
vestigated. Two research questions directed this exploratory study: (1
) How do students assess the efficiency of instructional interventions
; and (2) Do differences in gender, educational background, and/or sub
ject of study affect evaluations of the efficiency of instructional in
terventions. Results show that respondents regard regular instructiona
l interventions at the university directed toward, or supporting, surf
ace-level processing and reproduction to be highly efficient. The use
of technology is conceived as inefficient by these students. The limit
ed number of differences between groups of students also suggests stud
ents' conceptions to be both consistent and robust. The study illustra
tes the need to investigate instructional metacognitive knowledge as d
istinct from other forms of metacognitive knowledge, and raises questi
ons about the major components and structure of instructional metacogn
itive knowledge and individual differences in it. The findings suggest
the need for the elaboration of a framework to describe instructional
interventions.