Pursuing answers to the twin questions of when and why women engage in
''modest'' self-presentation, this study examined the self-presentati
on of academic achievement in a college setting. Gender of the partici
pants, gender of the partners, and vulnerability (concern over his/her
low grades or not) of the partner were completely crossed. Participan
ts were 85 first-year students, drawn from a college population that w
as 6% African-American 9% Asian, 79% Euro-American and 5% Latino/a. Th
ey heard information about a partner's academic record, and then were
induced to predict their own grade point average, in a context in whic
h they anticipated interacting closely with the partner on a joint tas
k. Women's grade point average predictions were lower than men's and p
articularly so when the partner was vulnerable. Vulnerable male partne
rs were particularly salient for women in both the grade point average
predictions and self-report data; the nonvulnerable male partners wer
e particularly salient for men. Results are discussed with reference t
o self-in-relation and social comparison theories.