S. Ramachandran et al., DIAMONDBACK MOTH (LEPIDOPTERA, PLUTELLIDAE) RESISTANCE OF BRASSICA-NAPUS AND BRASSICA-OLERACEA LINES WITH DIFFERING LEAF CHARACTERISTICS, Journal of economic entomology, 91(4), 1998, pp. 987-992
Canola quality oil produced from oilseed rape, Brassica napus L. (Bras
sicaceae), is a relatively new crop in the United States and is damage
d by a number of insect pests, including the crucifer specialist diamo
ndback moth, Plutella xylostella (L.). Greenhouse tests were performed
to evaluate resistance in normal-leafed ('Bingo','Cobra', 'Oscar') an
d glossy-leafed B, napus plants ('glossy Bingo' and plant introduction
s (PI) 469895, 470055, 470055-2, and 470064) to identify potential res
istant sources to diamondback moth. Normal-leafed PI 171538, originall
y described as B. napus and recently reclassified as B. oleracea, also
was evaluated for resistance with B. napus plants and B. oleracea cul
tivars of broccoli, 'Green Comet', 'Green Valiant', and collard 'Vates
'. Plants of Cornell line 92-8611, a broccoli with glossy-leaf type (g
lossy broccoli), were used as the resistant control in all trials. B.
napus entries failed to show feeding nonpreference or antibiosis compa
rable to that of glossy broccoli. Furthermore, no significant differen
ces were detected between normal and glossy-leafed B. napus lines for
most of the parameters tested. Within the tested B. napus entries, PI
470055 exhibited low levels of feeding damage in the restricted-feedin
g test and some level of antibiosis against diamondback moth. However,
B. oleracea entry PI 171538 showed a greater or comparable level of r
esistance to that of glossy broccoli. Nonpreference for larval feeding
and adult oviposition were exhibited by PI 171538. In feeding tests,
PI 171538 was less defoliated compared with other B. oleracea entries.
Diamondback moth larvae reared on PI 171538 leaves for 5 d had a lowe
r head capsule width compared with larvae reared on other entries. In
an oviposition preference test, PI 171538 received 0.9% of eggs as com
pared with normal-leafed B. napus plants (2.1- 4.4%) and glossy brocco
li, which received 7.0% of eggs. The experiments indicate that the nor
mal-leafed B. oleracea entry PI171538 has considerable resistance agai
nst diamondback moth. PI171538 is a newly discovered source of resista
nce and has leaf characteristics that differ from the previously repor
ted diamondback moth-resistant B, oleracea lines.