Bi. Dvorak et al., SELECTING AMONG PHYSICAL CHEMICAL PROCESSES FOR REMOVING SYNTHETIC ORGANICS FROM WATER/, Water environment research, 65(7), 1993, pp. 827-838
A rational framework for selecting the least-cost treatment technology
for aqueous organic wastes was developed by using performance and cos
t models. The following three treatment options were evaluated for 15
different chemicals in this research: packed tower air stripping, pack
ed tower air stripping followed by gas-phase adsorption (granular acti
vated carbon) of off-gases, and liquid-phase adsorption (granular acti
vated carbon). The least-cost air stripping tower design was found to
change when off-gas treatment was added. Air stripping without off-gas
treatment was determined to be less expensive than liquid-phase adsor
ption in nearly every case. A methodology was created for comparing th
e relative costs of liquid-phase adsorption and air stripping with gas
-phase adsorption. The comparison methodology is based upon physical p
arameters of the target chemical: Henry's constant and the solute dist
ribution parameter. The result is a diagram for rapid identification o
f cases for which one treatment option is significantly less expensive
than the other.