Measurements of the rate of biodegradation of crude oil in seawater in
laboratory, mesocosm, and field systems from 16 published reports wer
e reviewed and compared. Volumetric biodegradation rates range widely
from approximately 0.01 to 1 000 gC/m(3)-d. Laboratory studies report
rates at the higher end of this range, while field and mesocosm studie
s, of which there are fewer, suggest much lower rates ranging from 0.0
1 to 0.3 gC/m(3)-d. Possible explanations for the discrepancy between
measurements made at different scales are differences in oil concentra
tion and in mixing energy. When temperature-scaled degradation rates f
rom all systems are plotted versus initial oil concentration on a log-
log scale, the data are approximately linear (r(2) = 0.86) over severa
l orders of magnitude. The slope of the regressed line is near 1, indi
cating that the process can be interpreted as first order with respect
to oil concentration. The half-life for biodegradation is estimated t
o be approximately two months at 20 degrees C. This analysis suggests
that crude oil biodegradation in seawater is relatively slow and indic
ates that further research is required to bridge the gap between labor
atory and field systems.