Mr. Link et Rm. Peterman, ESTIMATING THE VALUE OF IN-SEASON ESTIMATES OF ABUNDANCE OF SOCKEYE-SALMON (ONCORHYNCHUS-NERKA), Canadian journal of fisheries and aquatic sciences, 55(6), 1998, pp. 1408-1418
Fishwheels have recently replaced a gillnet test fishery for in-season
estimation of escapement of sockeye salmon (Oncorhynchus nerka) to th
e Nass River, British Columbia. We used an empirically based Monte Car
lo simulation model to estimate the potential benefits (in terms of fu
ture harvests) of using this new method. We found that using the infor
mation from the fishwheels in place of the gillnet test fishery may in
crease the average annual catch from current ocean fisheries by 2.7% (
$229 000) due to the greater accuracy of in-season estimates. When the
additional costs of operating the fishwheels instead of the gillnet t
est fishery were taken into account, the fishwheel program still resul
ted in an annual net benefit of about $180 000. Eliminating the deviat
ions from the target escapement for Nass River sockeye salmon by havin
g perfect monitoring of escapement and perfect control over harvesting
has a potential annual value of more than $1 million (CAN). However,
much greater benefits from fishwheels are unlikely to be realized beca
use of the highly variable response of the commercial fishing fleet to
additional fishing opportunities and the 5-day lag of the escapement
estimates provided by fishwheels.