The finance minister in his budget speech has stated that a Constituti
on amendment bill will soon be brought forward in the parliament to gi
ve effect to the tenth Finance Commission's recommendations on an alte
rnative tax devolution scheme. In this paper it is argued that althoug
h the initiative is in the right direction, it does not go far enough.
A well thought out reform should address reforms in tax devolution al
ong with the issue of reassignment to evolve a co-ordinated system of
domestic trade taxes. In particular, to design and implement a destina
tion based consumption type value added tax (VAT), the states should b
e enabled to extend their sales taxes to services in addition to goods
. Further, an efficient and equitable tax system should prevent the le
vy of sales taxes on inter-state sale. Reforms in tax devolution shoul
d be addressed in conjunction with evolving rational, co-ordinated dom
estic trade taxes to bring about a structured reform of the fiscal sys
tem in Indian federalism.