Rj. Kinzler et Tl. Grove, CORRECTIONS AND FURTHER DISCUSSION OF THE PRIMARY MAGMAS OF MIDOCEAN RIDGE BASALTS, 1 AND 2, J GEO R-SOL, 98(B12), 1993, pp. 22339-22347
An error has been detected in the methodology for estimating batch mel
t compositions from plagioclase and spinel lherzolites at mantle condi
tions presented by Kinzler and Grove (1992a,b) (hereafter referred to
as K&G). In a mass balance calculation employed by K&G the melt fracti
on was not properly transformed from weight units to molar units, resu
lting in an overestimate of the effective melt fraction employed in th
e calculation of the Mg # (Mg/[Mg+Fe2+]) of the melt, at melt fraction
s greater than 0.01. In the batch melts estimated by K&G, the abundanc
e of FeO increases then decreases in the melt with increasing melt fra
ction from 0.01 to 0.20. Using the corrected methodology described her
e, the abundance of FeO in melts produced via batch melting increases
as melt fraction increases from 0.01 to 0.20 (up to the point of exhau
stion of clinopyroxene). The correction has essentially no effect on t
he compositions of melts produced via the near-fractional melting proc
esses described in K&G because melt fractions employed in the near-fra
ctional melting calculations never exceeded 0.01. In addition we apply
the methodology of K&G to estimate the mantle temperature, average pr
essure of melting and average extent of melting beneath a mid-ocean ri
dge segment from the FeO and Na2O content of a mid-ocean ridge basalt
from that segment.