Background: The value of physical examination in detecting involved ne
ck muscles in cervical dystonia (CD) is uncertain and little is known
about changes in electromyographic (EMG) features after botulinum toxi
n type A (BTA) treatment. Methods: In a double-blind, randomized study
we recorded the EMG activities of 420 neck muscles in 42 patients wit
h CD before and after treatment with BTA or trihexyphenidyl. We regard
ed any needle EMG activity higher than 100 mu V as the gold standard f
or involuntary involvement of a muscle in the dystonic posture and com
pared this with the results of physical examination. We calculated EMG
total scores by adding the scores of the individual muscles. Results:
Physical examination had a low predictive value in the detection of i
nvolved muscles. There was a significant correlation between changes i
n EMG total scores and changes in clinical measurements. We observed i
ncreased EMG activity in 20% of noninjected muscles after BTA treatmen
t and in 27% of noninjected muscles after trihexyphenidyl treatment. A
switch from one most active muscle to another was seen equally in bot
h groups and had no influence on clinical response. Conclusion: Physic
al examination alone is not sufficient to detect involved muscles, and
repeated, simultaneous EMG-guided application of BTA may be helpful.
In addition to clinical measurements, changes in EMG activity due to t
reatment can be used as a physiologic measure in evaluating treatment
response. Increased activity of noninjected muscles and a switch from
one most active muscle to another are not related to BTA treatment, bu
t are probably pathophysiologic phenomena of CD itself.