Although the increased mobilization of aluminum from soils to surface
waters is widely recognized as one of the most important ecological ef
fects of acidic deposition, lumped-parameter mathematical models of ac
idification response typically overestimate the change in Al concentra
tion under changing deposition by a considerable margin. The assumptio
n of equilibrium with gibbsite (Al(OH)(3)) in the MAGIC model and othe
r models of acid-base chemistry is shown to be inconsistent with measu
red values for a large variety of lake and stream databases. A modifie
d algorithm for predicting Al concentration, based on empirical relati
onships evident in field data: provided superior estimates of changes
in Al concentration in three long-term monitoring data sets and under
experimental conditions at two experimental watershed manipulation sit
es.