Several studies have confirmed an initial report of a relation between
bone density and polymorphic forms of the calcitriol (vitamin D) rece
ptor gene, whereas others have failed to find an association. We exami
ned whether variants of the vitamin D receptor gene are associated wit
h the risk of bone fracture, using a nested case-control analysis with
in the Nurses' Health Study cohort. The study women all were Caucasian
and were 43-69 years of age when they provided a blood sample. Cases
included the 54 proximal femur (hip) fractures and 163 distal radius (
forearm) fractures that occurred subsequent to the blood draw. Cases a
nd controls were genotyped by polymerase chain reaction for the BsmI p
olymorphism. The BE genotype, previously associated with lower bone de
nsity, was associated with a more than twofold increased risk of hip f
racture compared with the bb genotype. Risk was greater for women who
were older, leaner, or less physically active or who had a lower calci
um intake. The heterozygous genotype was not associated with any incre
ased risk of hip fracture, and we observed little association between
vitamin D receptor genotype and forearm fracture. This study supports
an association between vitamin D receptor genotype and hip fracture. I
t also implies that modification by other risk factors may have contri
buted to the conflicting results from previous studies of vitamin D re
ceptor genotype and femoral bone density.