M. Nigam et al., GENERATION AND STUDY OF BENZYLCHLOROCARBENE FROM A PHENANTHRENE PRECURSOR, Journal of the American Chemical Society, 120(32), 1998, pp. 8055-8059
The curved plots of (carbene adduct)/(carbene-rearrangement product) v
ersus carbene trapping agent, tetramethylene [TME], reported with benz
ylchlorodiazirine 1 have been reproduced. However, with the use of a n
on-nitrogenous precursor, plots of this type are approximately linear
over the range of [TME] employed. Thus, any complex formed between ben
zylchlorocarbene and TME must collapse to form cyclopropane faster the
n it can fragment with rearrangement to beta-chlorostyrene and TME. Di
azirine 1 does photoisomerize to diazo compound 7, but this process is
inefficient (phi = 0.075) and is not likely to be responsible for the
curvature in plots of adduct/styrene versus [TME] observed with the d
iazirine precursor. Thus, the second, noncarbene, pathway to beta-chlo
rostyrene is neither a carbene-olefin complex nor a diazo intermediate
. It is proposed that the second pathway involves a rearrangement in t
he excited stale of the diazirine, although other explanations cannot
be discarded.