Australia and South Africa are dominated by extensive agriculture, bot
h countries being predominantly arid and exposed to a highly variable
climate. Limiting land degradation, maintaining the financial viabilit
y of farms and improving the risk-management skills of farmers are com
mon problems which government and industry in both countries are attem
pting to address. Both countries are currently refining their approach
es to drought management, and have been making substantial use of scie
nce in improving the monitoring and assessment of drought, and the man
agement of the land. Unlike the situation in Australia, however, South
Africa's approach is being reviewed against the backdrop of a fundame
ntal reorientation of broader agricultural policies in the context of
that country's transition to a fully fledged democracy. The changing a
pproach to drought policy in South Africa can therefore only be fully
understood in the context of this broader process of change. This pape
r compares the climate and agriculture of Australia and South Africa,
and how their different drought policies have evolved. Observations ar
e made on the role of scientists in providing advice to political deci
sion makers, and ways in which the process of decision making with res
pect to drought may be improved. (C) 1998 Elsevier Science Ltd. All ri
ghts reserved.