To illuminate the complex ways in which a strong athletic identity can
act as an Achilles' heel in coming to terms with a disruptive life ev
ent, this article presents biographical data of one elite athlete whos
e career was prematurely terminated by illness. The analysis reveals h
ow, as an individual descends from the heights of the extraordinary in
to the mundane world of ordinariness, the loss of certain selves enfor
ces a heightened reflexivity and awareness of previously taken-for-gra
nted aspects of the body-self relationship that are no longer attainab
le. The manner in which certain selves at the apex of an identity hier
archy exert pressure on the individual to seek a restored self rather
than opt for more attainable or realistic identifies is highlighted. T
he problems of restorying the self when an individual is constrained b
y limited narrative resources are also considered. Finally, some impli
cations of the findings for health care professionals are discussed.