S. Borella et al., REDUCING UNCERTAINTIES IN DELTA-C-13 ANALYSIS OF TREE-RINGS - POOLING, MILLING, AND CELLULOSE EXTRACTION, J GEO RES-A, 103(D16), 1998, pp. 19519-19526
Recent developments of on-line methods have provided another boost to
the determination of stable isotope ratios in organic material. Along
with a significant increase in sample throughput, the sample sizes dec
rease, both of which are necessary conditions to acquire long time ser
ies from limited wood amounts. In view of this new technique we recons
idered the most important factors influencing the measured isotopic si
gnature which are (1) pooling, (2) homogeneity, and (3) cellulose extr
action. In most cases, pooling (i.e., mixing wood of the same year fro
m different trees) can be made in a simple way by mixing the whole woo
d available because mass-weighted and unweighted isotope measurements
were the same within the error. More attention must be paid in homogen
izing the sample. Theoretical considerations underpinned by experiment
al results suggest a fineness of 0.15 mm (115 mesh) if cellulose is ex
tracted and 0.1 mm (165 mesh) for direct wood analysis. Many of previo
us studies did not achieve this fineness. We find that wood is as good
a climate proxy as cellulose. This is shown by comparing correlations
of wood and corresponding cellulose isotope values with meteorologica
l data, which are identical within the uncertainty.