PREDICTIVE VALUE OF AGE-RELATED ACUTE INSULIN-RESPONSE TO GLUCOSE IN SUBJECTS AT RISK FOR TYPE-1 DIABETES - RESULTS OF A 6-YEAR FOLLOW-UP-STUDY FROM WEST-FRANCE
S. Bardet et al., PREDICTIVE VALUE OF AGE-RELATED ACUTE INSULIN-RESPONSE TO GLUCOSE IN SUBJECTS AT RISK FOR TYPE-1 DIABETES - RESULTS OF A 6-YEAR FOLLOW-UP-STUDY FROM WEST-FRANCE, Diabete et metabolisme, 19(4), 1993, pp. 372-380
The acute insulin response to i.v. glucose (AIRG) was evaluated in 344
first-degree relatives of patients with Type 1 diabetes. In 318 relat
ives aged 3 to 48 years without islet cell antibody and insulin autoan
tibody, correlations (p < 0.0006) were found between age and fasting i
nsulinaemia, fasting glycaemia, or AIRG, with a peak during puberty. A
ssuming that these relatives without islet cells and insulin auto-anti
bodies have a low risk of developping Type 1 diabetes, we provided a <
< standard age-related chart >> for AIRG with a << low >> AIRG defined
as a value below the 1st percentile for each pubertal stage. Using th
ese cut-off points, predictive characteristics of a low AIRG for progr
ession towards diabetes within 6 years were analysed. Four relatives d
eveloped diabetes and one displayed impaired oral glucose tolerance. F
our out of these 5 subjects had islet cell and insulin auto-antibodies
, but the other one was negative for these markers. Three of these 5 s
ubjects had low AIRG at entry (30, 24 and 1 months before diabetes, re
spectively). The two others displayed a steady progressive decline (p
< 0.02) of age-related during the follow-up before impaired oral gluco
se tolerance and diabetes appeared (rate of decline: 15 mu U/ ml/year)
. Thus, independently of the presence of Islet cell antibodies, the pr
edictive value of a low age-related AIRG during the follow-up is great
er than the single low AIRG at entry. Above all, the concomitant prese
nce of both islet cell antibodies and low age-related AIRG during the
follow-up strongly enhances the prediction of the disease, as compared
to the presence of islet cell antibodies alone. Additionally, 4 islet
cell antibody positive transient hyperglycaemic subjects without a fa
mily history of diabetes were prospectively studied. They rapidely pro
gressed to Type 1 diabetes (3-14 months) with a low initial AIRG (3/4
< 1st percentile; 1/4 < 3rd percentile at entry but falling below the
1st percentile 2 months before the onset of diabetes). Finally, in all
the subjects who subsequently developed diabetes (5 relatives and 4 t
ransiently hyperglycaemic subjects) and in whom the time-relationships
between basal glycaemia, oral glucose tolerance and AIRG were analyse
d in the short period preceeding the onset of the disease, we observed
that some subjects were still glucose tolerant at the time of the fir
st blunted AIRG but already displayed fasting blood glucose values at
the upper part of the normal range (> 90th percentile of control subje
cts). This suggests that the loss of AIRG, and even the slight rise of
fasting glycaemia, may precede the impairment of oral glucose toleran
ce. We conclude that the limited predictive value of islet cell antibo
dies can be overcome by a several-step procedure. As the initial scree
ning method, islet cell antibody testing with a low detection threshol
d to maximize sensitivity, identifies individuals to which the followu
p of age-related AIRG can then be applied to strongly improve the pred
ictive value. In subjects with a low age-related AIRG, determinations
of fasting glycaemia and oral glucose tolerance could then indicate a
worsening of the course and aid to predict the time to development of
the disease.