Dr. Reed et Ra. Price, ESTIMATES OF THE HEIGHTS AND WEIGHTS OF FAMILY MEMBERS - ACCURACY OF INFORMANT REPORTS, International journal of obesity, 22(9), 1998, pp. 827-835
OBJECTIVE: Information about the accuracy of family informant estimate
s of height and weight should assist investigators in evaluating the c
osts and benefits of using this type of data in genetic study designs.
DESIGN AND METHOD: To assess the accuracy of family informant estimat
es, 374 first-degree relatives from 94 Caucasian families, gave estima
tes about the heights and weights of their first degree relatives. The
se estimates were compared with measured heights and weights to determ
ine their accuracy. RESULTS: informant estimates were highly predictiv
e of measured heights (r = 0.95), and weights (r = 0.94), but informan
ts systematically overestimated heights (mean = 1.4 cm) and underestim
ated weights of their family members (mean = 4.1 kg). CONCLUSIONS: On
average, height estimates were generally within 1% of the measured hei
ght and weight estimates were within 3-5% of the measured weight. Ther
efore. these proxy measures can provide useful data, when measured or
self-reported heights and weights are not available.