A. Ysunza et al., SPEECH OUTCOME AND MAXILLARY GROWTH IN PATIENTS WITH UNILATERAL COMPLETE CLEFT LIP PALATE OPERATED ON AT 6 VERSUS 12 MONTHS OF AGE/, Plastic and reconstructive surgery, 102(3), 1998, pp. 675-679
A prospective study of speech outcome and maxillofacial growth was car
ried out in cleft palate patients. Seventy-six cleft palate patients w
ere randomly selected for the study group; 41 patients were operated o
n at 12 months of age, and 35 patients were operated on at 6 months of
age. All patients were followed until they were 4 years of age. All p
atients underwent a complete speech evaluation, videonasopharyngoscopy
, videofluoroscopy, and maxillofacial assessment. The rate of velophar
yngeal insufficiency did not differ between the two groups (17 to 19 p
ercent; p > 0.05). However, phonologic development was significantly b
etter (p < 0.05) in the patients operated on at 6 months of age. Furth
ermore, none of the patients operated on at 6 months of age showed com
pensatory articulation disorder. In contrast, 62 percent of the patien
ts with postoperative velopharyngeal insufficiency operated on at 12 m
onths of age showed compensatory articulation disorder (p < 0.05). Max
illofacial assessment showed that there were nonsignificant difference
s (p > 0.05) in maxillofacial growth in both groups of patients. All p
atients showed similar degrees of maxillary collapse (p > 0.05). The r
esults of this study suggest that cleft palate repair performed at 6 m
onths of age significantly enhances speech outcome and prevents compen
satory articulation disorder.