Sa. Betchen et Rl. Doty, BILATERAL DETECTION THRESHOLDS IN DEXTRALS AND SINISTRALS REFLECT THEMORE SENSITIVE SIDE OF THE NOSE, WHICH IS NOT LATERALIZED, Chemical senses, 23(4), 1998, pp. 453-457
Several fundamental questions remain enigmatic concerning human olfact
ory sensitivity, including (i) whether detection threshold differences
exist between the two sides of the nose (and, if so, whether such dif
ferences are influenced by handedness) and (ii) whether bilateral (i.e
. binasal) stimulation leads to lower thresholds than unilateral stimu
lation (and, if so, whether the degree of facilitation is inversely re
lated to general olfactory ability). In this study, a reliable and wel
l-validated single staircase procedure was used to establish bilateral
and unilateral detection thresholds for the cranial nerve I stimulant
phenyl ethyl alcohol in 130 right- and 33 left-handed subjects. No di
fferences in sensitivity between the left and right sides of the nose
were observed in either group. Bilateral thresholds were lower, on ave
rage, than unilateral thresholds when the latter were categorized in t
erms of left and right nares. However, the bilateral thresholds did no
t differ significantly from those of the side of the nose with the low
er threshold. Overall smell ability, as measured by the University of
Pennsylvania Smell identification Test, did not interact with any of t
he rest measures. These data imply that (i) the left and right sides o
f the nose do not systematically differ in detection threshold sensiti
vity for either dextrals or sinistrals and (ii) if central integration
of left:right olfactory threshold sensitivity occurs, its effects do
not exceed the function of the better side of the nose.