Re. Mcginnis, HIDDEN LINKAGE - A COMPARISON OF THE AFFECTED SIB PAIR (ASP) TEST ANDTRANSMISSION DISEQUILIBRIUM TEST (TDT)/, Annals of Human Genetics, 62, 1998, pp. 159-179
I compare the transmission/disequilibrium test (TDT) and affected sib
pair (ASP) test under a general algebraic model describing a bi-alleli
c disease locus. Assuming linkage to a bi-allelic marker, I derive two
binomial probabilities, one for parental allele 'transmission' (P-t)
which determines the magnitude of the TDT chi(2) statistic (chi(tdt)(2
)), and a second for identity-by-descent (ibd) marker allele 'sharing'
(P-s) which determines the magnitude of the ASP test statistic ( chi(
asp)(2)). I also consider the SSP test applied to a completely polymor
phic marker and demonstrate that the probability of ASP marker allele
sharing (P-s) is identical to P-s observed for a bi-allelic marker in
equilibrium with the disease locus. I present a general framework for
determining the power of the TDT and BSP test based. on expressions fo
r P-t, P-s and the proportion (H/F) of ascertained parents who are inf
ormative at the marker. Two previous analytic investigations of TDT po
wer based on the work of Ott (1989), and Risch & Merikangas (1996) are
shown to be special cases of this general framework. In addition, I s
how the relationship between the framework I present and a third analy
tic investigation of TDT power for multi-allelic markers based on the
work of Sham & Curtis (1995).