The relation between plant growth rate and respiration rate is readily
derived from the overall chemical reaction for aerobic metabolism. Th
e derived relation can be used to show that separation of respiration
into growth (g) and maintenance (m) components is not a useful concept
, g and m cannot be unambiguously measured or defined in terms of bioc
hemical processes. Moreover, because growth yield calculations from bi
ochemical pathway analysis, from biomass molecular composition, from b
iomass heat of combustion, and from biomass elemental composition have
not included all of the energy costs for biosynthesis, they are not a
ccurate measures of the carbon cost for plant growth. Improper definit
ions of growth-respiration relations are impeding the use of physiolog
ical properties for prediction of plant growth as a function of enviro
nmental variables.