Dj. Houghton et al., ROLE OF CHEST CT SCANNING IN THE MANAGEMENT OF PATIENTS PRESENTING WITH HEAD AND NECK-CANCER, Head & neck, 20(7), 1998, pp. 614-618
Background. The detection of synchronous tumors, whether they be secon
d primaries or distant metastases, in patients with head and neck carc
inoma drastically affects prognosis and may alter management. Computer
ized tomographic (CT) scanning of the chest is an effective screening
investigation in this group of patients, both in the detection of sync
hronous second primary tumors, the incidence of which in this study is
15%, and for accurate staging of metastatic pulmonary disease. The in
cidence of synchronous tumors in patients who are initially seen with
head and neck squamous cell carcinoma (HNSCC) has been reported in lar
ge retrospective studies as being between 1% and 3%. These may be eith
er second primary tumors or metastases, and the lung is the commonest
site for both. Methods. Eighty-one head and neck cancer patients (67 p
rimary and 14 secondary referrals) treated at the Royal Liverpool Univ
ersity Hospital between 1994 and 1996 underwent CT scanning of the che
st with ultrasound of the liver as part of their routine staging. The
results were compared with standard chest x-rays also performed in eac
h patient. Results. Fourteen patients had pulmonary tumors detected on
the chest CT scan. In 67 patients, the scan was negative. Patients wi
th negative scans tended not to have neck node metastases (64%), where
as patients with positive scans were much more likely to have neck nod
e metastases with negative necks present in only 36% of patients. Wher
e multivariate analysis was carried out. there was a correlation betwe
en neck node metastases and positive CT scans of the chest (estimate =
0.5755, standard error = 0.3066, X-1(2) = 6.73, p .047). The sensitiv
ity of chest x-ray compared with CT scan was only 21% and the specific
ity 99%. The positive predictive value of a chest x-ray was 75% and th
e negative predictive value 86%. Intra-abdominal lesions were detected
in two patients, one in the liver and one in the adrenal gland. In th
e latter patient. this was an isolated lesion, but in the former, the
chest scan was also positive. In the 67 patients, who were initially s
een at the Royal Liverpool Hospital (primary referrals), the incidence
of synchronous tumors was 15%. Conclusions. Synchronous tumors, wheth
er they be second primary tumors or distant metastases, are more commo
n in patients initially seen with head and neck cancer than is realize
d, their incidence being significantly higher in those patients with c
ervical metastases. Computerized tomographic scanning of the chest is
a more effective screening investigation than chest x-ray in this grou
p of patients and is now used routinely in our department prior to und
ertaking major head and neck surgery. (C) 1998 John Wiley & Sons, Inc.