Sj. Emans et al., ADOLESCENT MEDICINE TRAINING IN PEDIATRIC RESIDENCY PROGRAMS - ARE WEDOING A GOOD JOB, Pediatrics (Evanston), 102(3), 1998, pp. 588-595
Objectives. To determine how pediatric residency programs are respondi
ng to the new challenges of teaching adolescent medicine (AM) to resid
ents by assessing whether manpower is adequate for training, whether A
M curricula and skills are adequately covered by training programs, wh
at types of teaching methodologies are used to train residents in AM,
and the needs for new curricular materials to teach AM. Design. A 3-pa
rt 92-item survey mailed to all US pediatric residency training progra
ms. Setting. Pediatric residency programs. Participants. Residency pro
gram directors and directors of AM training. Main Outcome Measures. AM
divisional structure, clinical sites of training, presence of a block
rotation, and faculty of pediatric training programs; training materi
als used and desired in AM; perceived adequacy of coverage of various
AM topics; competency of residents in performing pelvic examinations i
n sexually active teens; and manpower needs. Results. A total of 155/2
11 (73.5%) of programs completed the program director and the AM parts
of the survey. Ninety-six percent of programs (size range, 5-120 resi
dents) had an AM block rotation and 90% required the AM block; those w
ithout a block rotation were more likely to be larger programs. Only 3
9% of programs felt that the number of AM faculty was adequate for tea
ching residents. Almost half of the programs reported lack of time, fa
culty, and curricula to teach content in substance abuse. Besides phys
icians, AM teachers included nurse practitioners (28%), psychologists
(25%), and social workers (19%). Topics most often cited as adequately
covered included sexually transmitted diseases (81.9%), confidentiali
ty (79.4%), puberty (77.0%), contraception (76.1%), and menstrual prob
lems (73.5%). Topics least often cited as adequately covered included
psychological testing (16.1%), violence in relationships (20.0%), viol
ence and weapon-carrying (29.7%), and sports medicine (29.7%). Fifty-e
ight percent of 137 respondents thought that all or nearly all of thei
r residents were competent in performing pelvic examinations by the en
d of training; there was no difference between perceived competence an
d the residents' use of procedure books. Seventy-four percent used a s
pecific curriculum for teaching AM; materials included chapters/articl
es (85%), lecture outlines (76.1%), slides (41.9%), videos (35.5%), wr
itten ease studies (24.5%), computerized cases (6.5%), and CD-ROMs (3.
2%). Fifty-two percent used Bright Futures, 48% used the Guidelines fo
r Adolescent Preventive Services, and 14% used the Guide to Clinical P
reventive Services for teaching clinical preventive services. Programs
that used Bright Futures were more likely to feel that preventive ser
vices were adequately covered in their programs than those who did not
(78% vs 57%). A majority of programs desired more learner-centered ma
terials. Conclusions. Although almost all pediatric programs are now p
roviding AM rotations, there is significant variability in adequacy of
training across multiple topics important for resident education. Pro
grams desire more learner-centered materials and more faculty to provi
de comprehensive resident education in AM.