BIOELECTRICAL-IMPEDANCE ANALYSIS IN HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY VIRUS-INFECTED PATIENTS - COMPARISON OF SINGLE-FREQUENCY WITH MULTIFREQUENCY, SPECTROSCOPY, AND OTHER NOVEL APPROACHES
Ni. Paton et al., BIOELECTRICAL-IMPEDANCE ANALYSIS IN HUMAN IMMUNODEFICIENCY VIRUS-INFECTED PATIENTS - COMPARISON OF SINGLE-FREQUENCY WITH MULTIFREQUENCY, SPECTROSCOPY, AND OTHER NOVEL APPROACHES, Nutrition, 14(9), 1998, pp. 658-666
Bioelectrical impedance (BIA), a prediction method for estimating body
water compartments and body cell mass (BCM), is being increasingly us
ed in studies of human immunodeficiency virus (HIV)-related wasting, b
ut there are few validation studies of the method in this group. The a
im of this study is to examine the relationship between impedance meas
urements and body water compartments in patients with advanced HN dise
ase, and to investigate whether the newer approaches of multifrequency
BIA, BIA spectroscopy, logarithmic transformation using a parallel ci
rcuit model, and direct calculation from electrical theory offer any a
dvantage over traditional single-frequency BIA. We measured total body
water (TBW) by deuterium dilution and extracellular water by bromide
dilution in 33 patients with advanced HIV disease. Intracellular water
and BCM were calculated from these results. Impedance was measured ov
er a range of frequencies using a multifrequency analyzer. The relatio
nship between impedance index at various frequencies and body water co
mpartments was assessed by correlation and linear regression. We found
that impedance index at higher frequencies had a closer relationship
to TBW (r = 0.86, standard error of the estimate [SEE] = 2.96 at 1000
kHz) and at lower frequencies a closer relationship to extracellular w
ater (ECW) (r = 0.47, SEE = 3.13 at 0 kHz) than the traditional 50 kHz
measurement (r = 0.84, SE = 3.11 for TBW; r = 0.44, SEE = 3.19 for EC
W), but the differences were marginal and not statistically significan
t. None of the other novel approaches tested were significantly better
than traditional single frequency measurement. The 50 kHz equation fo
r BCM developed in this study [BCM (kg) = (0.360331 x Ht(2)/Z(50)) + (
0.151123 x Wt) - 2.95] may be useful to investigators using BIA for HI
V-wasting studies. Nutrition 1998; 14:658-666. (C) Elsevier Science In
c. 1998.