Ra. Isabella, ORIGINS OF ATTACHMENT - THE ROLE OF CONTEXT, DURATION, FREQUENCY OF OBSERVATION, AND INFANT AGE IN MEASURING MATERNAL-BEHAVIOR, Journal of social and personal relationships, 15(4), 1998, pp. 538-554
A total of 32 Caucasian women and their first-born infants (16 male, 1
6 female) were observed in multiple naturalistic and single free-play
interactions at 1-, 4- and 9-months infant age: setting and coding pro
cedures were held constant. Infant-mother attachment quality was asses
sed at 1 year. Analyses examined similarities among and differences be
tween data derived from the two interactional contexts, and the relati
ve utility of each in explaining individual differences in attachment
quality. Data from individual naturalistic observations were not as re
liable as data consolidated across naturalistic observations. Addition
ally, maternal sensitivity, as measured by repeated naturalistic obser
vations, was far superior to sensitivity measured in the free-play con
text in accounting for individual differences in attachment quality -
securely attached infants experienced higher levels of maternal sensit
ivity than did insecurely attached infants. Conversely, it was difficu
lt to distinguish between naturalistic and free-play measures of mater
nal rejection in terms of their ability to account for individual diff
erences in attach ment - at 1 month, insecure-resistant infants experi
enced the highest levels of maternal rejection.