Mf. Schmidt et al., APPLICABILITY OF HIGH-T(C) PARADIGMS TO MAGNETIC-RELAXATION AND IRREVERSIBILITY IN SUPERCONDUCTING NB, Physical review. B, Condensed matter, 48(5), 1993, pp. 3404-3416
Detailed measurements of the temperature and magnetic-field dependence
of the magnetization and the magnetic relaxation of Nb films have bee
n carried out. An irreversibility line, below which the remanent magne
tization decayed logarithmically in time, was identified. The data wer
e quantitatively compared to predictions of flux-creep, vortex-glass,
and vortex-lattice-melting models. Only the melting model self-consist
ently explained the data.