Sa. Stahmer et al., DO QUANTITATIVE CHANGES IN PAIN INTENSITY CORRELATE WITH PAIN RELIEF AND SATISFACTION, Academic emergency medicine, 5(9), 1998, pp. 851-857
Objective: To correlate measured pain intensity (PI) changes with pain
relief and satisfaction with pain management. Methods: A prospective
single-group repeated-measures design study. A heterogeneous group of
patients were asked to record their levels of PI at initial presentati
on and at ED release using a numerical descriptor scale (NDS) and a vi
sual analog scale (VAS). At release, a 5-point pain relief scale and a
pain management satisfaction survey were also completed. Results: A c
onvenience sample of 81 patients were enrolled over the study period.
The average reduction in PI for all patients was 33%. A 5%, 30%, and 5
7% reduction in PI correlated with ''no,'' some/partial,'' and ''signi
ficant/complete'' relief, respectively (p < 0.001). However, when pati
ents were divided into 2 groups based on their initial PI scores, pati
ents with moderate/severe pain (NDS > 5) required a reduction of 35% a
nd 84% in PI to achieve ''some/partial'' and ''significant/complete''
relief, respectively. Patients in less pain (NDS less than or equal to
5) needed 25% and 29% reductions in PI for the same categories (p = 0
.8). Patients were generally satisfied with their pain management. The
re was a positive association between pain relief and satisfaction wit
h pain management. Conclusion: There is a significant association betw
een changes in PI and pain relief Greater reductions in PI are require
d for patients presenting with more severe initial pain to achieve rel
ief compared with those who have lesser initial PI. While there is a l
inear relationship between increasing pain relief and satisfaction, re
lief of pain appears to only partially contribute to overall satisfact
ion with pain management.