Sd. Ards et al., IF IT SHALL SEEM JUST AND PROPER - THE EFFECT OF RACE AND MORALS ON ALIMONY AND CHILD-SUPPORT APPEALS IN THE DISTRICT-OF-COLUMBIA, 1950-1980, Journal of family history, 23(4), 1998, pp. 441-475
This article tests the hypothesis that judicial arbitrariness dominate
d alimony or child support appeals in the pre-no-fault era by analyzin
g data on all alimony and child support appeals in the District of Col
umbia from 1950 through 1980. Censored regression analysis is used to
isolate the impacts of race and morals grounds for divorce on changes
in alimony and child support awards from trial to appeal. The results
show large race effects but small morals effects. Judicial discretion-
measured by unexplained gaps in awards-dominated relevant economic fac
tors in determining changes in alimony and child support awards during
the pre-no-fault era.