INFLUENCES OF EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTIONS AND ADVERSE NEWS ABOUT CALCIUM-CHANNEL BLOCKERS ON FIRST-LINE PRESCRIBING OF ANTIHYPERTENSIVE DRUGSTO ELDERLY PEOPLE IN BRITISH-COLUMBIA
M. Maclure et al., INFLUENCES OF EDUCATIONAL INTERVENTIONS AND ADVERSE NEWS ABOUT CALCIUM-CHANNEL BLOCKERS ON FIRST-LINE PRESCRIBING OF ANTIHYPERTENSIVE DRUGSTO ELDERLY PEOPLE IN BRITISH-COLUMBIA, Lancet, 352(9132), 1998, pp. 943-948
Background The way in which dissemination of evidence changes medical
practice needs td be better understood. Controversy about calcium-chan
nel blockers (CCB) in the past 3 years has provided a natural experime
nt, enabling assessment of the impact of media stories, a national war
ning letter, a teleconference, small group workshops, and newsletters
on first-line prescribing of antihypertensive drugs. Methods We includ
ed all physicians (4403) in British Columbia who prescribed a thiazide
diuretic, beta-blocker, inhibitor of angiotensin-converting enzyme (A
CE), or CCB as the first antihypertensive agent for 36 507 residents a
ged 66 years and over, with no previous or concurrent sign of underlyi
ng cardiovascular disease. We used a database covering all prescriptio
ns to elderly people to measure the change in proportion of newly trea
ted patients who received each class of drug as first-line therapy. We
used a matched cohort design for assessment of the teleconference and
workshops, a randomised community design for the newsletters, and tim
e-series analysis for the media impacts. Findings The proportion of pa
tients who received a CCB as first-line therapy declined gradually fro
m 22% in early 1994 to 15% in late 1996. This proportion was not affec
ted by two waves of adverse news about CCBs in 1995, but fell by 5% fo
r 5 months and by 3% for 1 month after two waves in 1996. The proporti
on of patients who received either a CCB or an ACE inhibitor as first-
fine therapy, contrary to guidelines, was still 42% overall in 1996. T
he workshops and newsletters were followed by shifts from first-line C
CB to first-line thiazide prescribing. Interpretation Changes in presc
ribing practices occur gradually with the accumulation of small impact
s from educational interventions and lay media attention.