CRYSTAL POLYMORPHISM IN PENDIMETHALIN HERBICIDE IS DRIVEN BY ELECTRONIC DELOCALIZATION AND CHANGES IN INTRAMOLECULAR HYDROGEN-BONDING - A CRYSTALLOGRAPHIC, SPECTROSCOPIC AND COMPUTATIONAL STUDY
Gw. Stockton et al., CRYSTAL POLYMORPHISM IN PENDIMETHALIN HERBICIDE IS DRIVEN BY ELECTRONIC DELOCALIZATION AND CHANGES IN INTRAMOLECULAR HYDROGEN-BONDING - A CRYSTALLOGRAPHIC, SPECTROSCOPIC AND COMPUTATIONAL STUDY, Journal of the Chemical Society. Perkin transactions. II (Print), (9), 1998, pp. 2061-2071
Pendimethalin, ethylpropyl)-3,4-dimethyl-2,6-dinitrobenzeneamine, is a
potent herbicide that exists in two differently coloured polymorphic
crystal habits. Triclinic pendimethalin I (P (1) over bar) is the oran
ge-coloured thermodynamically stable form, whereas monoclinic pendimet
halin II (P2(1)/c) is a bright-yellow metastable form. The latter is n
ormally produced first upon cooling the molten chemical, whereas the o
range form is formed by a polymorphic phase transition which occurs sl
owly upon long term storage of the yellow form at temperatures below i
ts melting point. Such phase transitions are rapidly revealed by calor
imetry. The crystal structures of the polymorphs have been determined
using single crystal X-ray diffraction, Solid state NMR spectroscopy,
vibrational spectroscopy and UV-VIS spectroscopy were applied to furth
er study the nature of the polymorphism in terms of intra- and inter-m
olecular properties. Solid state CP-MAS C-13 NMR spectroscopy was show
n to be the method of choice for quantitative analysis of polymorphic
mixtures. The differences in spectral properties and crystal habits we
re investigated by computational methods which included molecular exci
ton, molecular orbital and molecular mechanics calculations. The drama
tic colour change from yellow to orange-red during the polymorphic tra
nsition is discussed in terms of competing inter- and intra-molecular
electronic effects. The driving force for the yellow (II) to orange(I)
polymorphic transition is attributed to the change in the electronic
delocalization achieved from shortening, strengthening, and partially
straightening the 'bent' hydrogen bond between the secondary amino hyd
rogen and an oxygen of the 6'-nitro group. This results in increased o
verlap between the amino nitrogen's lone pair and the pi-electron orbi
tals of the aromatic ring. The calculated lattice stabilization energy
due to this process is 4 to 5 kcal mol(-1), and the relative lattice
energies are consistent with the observed stabilities of the polymorph
s, The slow kinetics of the polymorphic transition are largely governe
d by the steric interaction of the 1-etlhylpropyl side chain and the t
wo nitro groups. During crystallization, the more compact side chain c
onformation required to form the energetically more stable orange (I)
polymorph appears to-be more difficult to achieve than that required f
or the yellow (II) polymorph.