Dl. Commins et Dr. Hinton, CYTOLOGIC FEATURES OF HEMANGIOBLASTOMA - COMPARISON WITH MENINGIOMA, ANAPLASTIC ASTROCYTOMA AND RENAL-CELL CARCINOMA, Acta cytologica, 42(5), 1998, pp. 1104-1110
OBJECTIVE: To compare the features of intraoperative smears of hemangi
oblastomas with those of tumors with which it is most likely to be con
fused: meningiomas, anaplastic astrocytomas and renal cell carcinomas.
STUDY DESIGN: Examples of hemangioblastomas with high-quality intraop
erative smears were retrieved from the files Oo University Hospital, U
niversity of Southern California and Los Angeles County-University of
Southern California. The characteristics of these smears were compared
to those of meningiomas, anaplastic astrocytomas and renal cell carci
nomas by two observers. RESULTS: Smears of hemangioblastomas were cell
ular but remarkably cohesive. Cytoplasmic borders were indistinct. he
nuclei were hyperchromatic and mildly pleomorphic and had a relatively
evenly dispersed chromatin pattern. Hemosiderin was invariably presen
t. Smears of meningiomas, anaplastic astrocytomas and renal cell carci
nomas were more discohesive than those of hemagioblastomas. Smears of
hemangioblastomas lacked the cytoplasmic fibrillarity of those of astr
ocytic neoplasms and distinct cytoplasmic borders seen in smears of re
nal cell carcinoma. The nuclear features of the four neoplasms studied
also differed. CONCLUSION: Smears ajc hemangioblastomas have characte
ristic features that differ reliably from those of meningiomas, anapla
stic astrocytoma and renal cell cinoma, neoplasms that commonly enter
the differential with hemangioblastoma. Thus, a cytologic smear prepar
ation made at the time of frozen section may be an invaluable aid in t
he intraoperative diagnosis of hemangioblastoma.