Cj. Webster, SUSTAINABILITY AND PUBLIC CHOICE - A THEORETICAL ESSAY ON URBAN PERFORMANCE INDICATORS, Environment and planning. B, Planning & design, 25(5), 1998, pp. 709-729
Liveable, endurable, and governable cities are sustained by a delicate
balance of laws and policies that protect the interests of individual
s, households, and firms at the same time as meeting the collective co
nsumption needs of existing and future citizens. A general equilibrium
model is developed in order to articulate some of the important theor
etical features of this problem of urban management. Central to the mo
del is the idea that sustainable policies and actions have themselves
to be sustainable and that this is possible only if they reflect the p
references of citizens. Starting from a household utility-maximisation
problem the model yields an equilibrium urban public goods matrix, de
signated the urban management matrix Gamma*, which may be viewed as a
socially efficient urban management objective function. It contains qu
antities of environmental goods, social infrastructure, and regulative
services that are socially optimal in the sense that any deviation fr
om them will make some citizens worse off. These are used to derive a
set of urban system performance indicators that represent a realistic
specification of a sustainable city from the current perspective of ci
tizens. The degree of environmental sustainability implicit in the ind
icators depends on the preferences of existing citizens for prudent co
llective action. The indicators represent the optimal prescription of
sustainable-city policies for present application. If pro-sustainabili
ty education and propaganda are successful in changing preferences ove
r time, then a comparative static use of the model charts a socially a
nd politically sustainable path towards longer term environmental sust
ainability. The essay is a theoretical one intended to explore the nat
ure of collective and individual consumption trade-offs in a sustainab
le city.