Background: The serine protease prostate-specific antigen (PSA) isa us
eful clinical marker for prostatic malignancy. PSA is a member of the
kallikrein subgroup of the (chymo)trypsin serine protease family, but
differs from the prototypical member of this subgroup, tissue kallikre
in, in possessing a specificity more similar to that of chymotrypsin t
han trypsin. We report the use of two strategies, substrate phage disp
lay and iterative optimization of natural cleavage sites, to identify
labile sequences for PSA cleavage. Results: Iterative optimization and
substrate phage display converged on the amino-acid sequence SS(Y/F)Y
down arrow S(G/S) as preferred subsite occupancy for PSA. These seque
nces were cleaved by PSA with catalytic efficiencies as high as 2200-3
100 M-1 s(-1), compared with values of 2-46 M-1 s(-1) for peptides con
taining likely physiological target sequences of PSA from the protein
semenogelin. Substrate residues that bind to secondary (non-S1) subsit
es have a critical role in defining labile substrates and can even cau
se otherwise disfavored amino acids to bind in the primary specificity
(S1) pocket. Conclusions: The importance of secondary subsites in def
ining both the specificity and efficiency of cleavage suggests that su
bstrate recognition by PSA is mediated by an extended binding site. El
ucidation of preferred subsite occupancy allowed refinement of the str
uctural model of PSA and should facilitate the development of more sen
sitive activity-based assays and the design of potent inhibitors.