Md. Lleo et al., NONCULTURABLE ENTEROCOCCUS-FAECALIS CELLS ARE METABOLICALLY ACTIVE AND CAPABLE OF RESUMING ACTIVE GROWTH, Systematic and applied microbiology, 21(3), 1998, pp. 333-339
Entry into the viable but nonculturable (VNC) state is a survival mech
anism that bacteria can adopt when they find themselves in an adverse
environment. When in this state, bacteria are still viable but are una
ble to form colonies on growth medium. The possibility of Gram-positiv
e species entering the VNC state when environmental conditions are adv
erse and remaining viable and capable of resuming active growth is dem
onstrated for the first time in this study by using exponential-phase
cultures of Enterococcus faecalis inoculated in filtered, sterilized w
ater from Lake Garda (Italy). Over the 60-day study, the number of tot
al cells stained with a fluorescent stain or counted with a Coulter Co
unter remained constant, while the number of cells capable of forming
colonies on Tryptic Soy Agar (TSA) declined rapidly from 10(6) CFU/ml
on day zero to 10(3) CFU/ml on day 4. On day 14 no colonies could be o
bserved when 50 ml of inoculated lake water were plated. E. faecalis c
ells conserved their viability while in the VNC state, as can be demon
strated by active uptake of amino acids, which are also incorporated i
nto proteins, and by continuous detection of E. faecalis specific DNA
by PCR throughout the experiment. The possibility of revival of the E.
faecalis cells in the VNC state when returned to conditions supportin
g its cell growth has also been demonstrated. The data obtained in thi
s study lend further support to recent criticisms of the traditional m
ethods used to evaluate water quality based on plate counts, assessing
fecal contamination indicators such as Escherichia coli and fecal str
eptococci.