Pn. Gordon et al., AS SEEN ON TV - OBSERVATIONAL STUDY OF CARDIOPULMONARY-RESUSCITATION IN BRITISH TELEVISION MEDICAL DRAMAS, BMJ. British medical journal, 317(7161), 1998, pp. 780-783
Objective: To determine the frequency and accuracy with which cardiopu
lmonary resuscitation is portrayed in British television medical drama
s. design: Observational study. Subjects: 64 episodes of three major B
ritish television medical dramas: Casualty, Cardiac Arrest, and Medics
. Main outcome measures: Frequency of cardiopulmonary resuscitation sh
own on television; age, sex, and diagnosis of the patients undergoing
resuscitation; rate of survival through resuscitation. Results: Overal
l 52 patients had a cardiorespiratory arrest on screen and 3 had a res
piratory arrest alone, all the arrests occurring in 40 of the 64 episo
des. Of the 52 patients having cardiorespiratory arrest, 32 (62%) unde
rwent an attempt at cardiopulmonary resuscitation; 8 attempts were suc
cessful. Al 3 of the patients having respiratory arrests alone receive
d ventilatory support and survived. On 48% of occasions, victims of ca
rdiac arrest seemed to be less than 35 years old. Conclusions: Cardior
espiratory resuscitation is often depicted in British television medic
al dramas. Patients portrayed receiving resuscitation are likely to be
in a younger age group than in real life. Though the reasons for resu
scitation are more varied and more often associated with trauma than i
n reality, the overall success rate is nevertheless realistic. Widespr
ead overoptimism of patients for survival after resuscitation cannot n
ecessarily be blamed on British television medical dramas.