A NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMINATION OF THE UNDERLYING DEFICIT IN ATTENTION-DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER - FRONTAL-LOBE VERSUS RIGHT PARIETALLOBE THEORIES
Cj. Aman et al., A NEUROPSYCHOLOGICAL EXAMINATION OF THE UNDERLYING DEFICIT IN ATTENTION-DEFICIT HYPERACTIVITY DISORDER - FRONTAL-LOBE VERSUS RIGHT PARIETALLOBE THEORIES, Developmental psychology, 34(5), 1998, pp. 956-969
A neuropsychological approach was used to examine the frontal lobe and
right parietal lobe theories of attention deficit hyperactivity disor
der (ADHD). Considerable attempts were made to select as pure a group
of ADHD boys as possible. The performance of 10-14-year-old ADHD boys
(n = 22), both on and off stimulant medication, was compared with the
performance of non-ADHD control boys (n = 22) on tasks purported to as
sess frontal lobe functioning (Stopping Task, Antisaccade Task, Tower
of Hanoi) and right parietal lobe functioning (Visual-Spatial Cuing Ta
sk, Turning Task, Spatial Relations). Three important findings emerged
: (a) unmedicated ADHD boys exhibited performance deficits on tasks in
both frontal and parietal domains compared with control boys, (b) unm
edicated ADHD boys appeared to be more severely impaired on the fronta
l tasks than on the parietal tasks, and (c) medicated ADHD boys perfor
med better in both task domains compared with unmedicated ADHD boys. S
everal alternative interpretations of the results are discussed.