M. Fulle et al., THE PREPERIHELION DUST ENVIRONMENT OF C 1995 O1 HALE-BOPP FROM 13 TO 4 AU/, The Astronomical journal (New York), 116(3), 1998, pp. 1470-1477
Two UK Schmidt plates of comet Hale-Bopp dust tail taken in 1996 May a
re analyzed by means of the inverse dust tail model. The dust tail fit
s are the only available tools providing estimates of the ejection vel
ocity, the dust-loss rate, and the size distribution of the dust grain
s ejected during years preceding the comet discovery. These quantities
describe the comet dust environment driven by CO sublimation between
1993 and 1996, when the comet approached the Sun from 13 to 4 AU. The
outputs of the model are consistent with the available coma photometry
, quantified by the Af rho quantity. The dust mass loss rate increases
from 500 to 8000 kg s(-1), these values being inversely proportional
to the dust albedo, assumed here to be 10%. Therefore, the mass ratio
between icy grains and CO results is at least 5. Higher values of the
dust-to-gas ratio are probable, because the model infers the dust-loss
rate over a limited size range, up to 1 mm sized grains, and because
the power-law index of the differential size distribution ranges betwe
en -3.5 and -4.0, so that most of the dust mass was ejected in the lar
gest boulders that Hale-Bopp was able to eject. The dust ejection velo
city close to the observations, between 7 and 4 AU, was close to 100 m
s(-1) for grains 10 mu m in size, much higher than that predicted by
R. F. Probstein's theory, thus confirming previous results of Neck-Lin
e photometry. This result is an indicator of CO superheating with resp
ect to a free sublimating CO ice, in agreement with the high observed
CO velocity. The fundamental result of the paper is that such a high d
ust velocity remained constant between 13 and 4 AU, thus providing a s
trong constraint to all models of the GO-driven activity of the comet
during its approach to the Sun: CO superheating must have been active
since 13 AU from the Sun. It might be provided by the abundant dust it
self, or by seasonal effects heating the subsurface layers, as was sug
gested for comet 29P/Schwassmann-Wachmann 1. Another similarity betwee
n the two comets is provided by the power-law index of the time-averag
ed size distributions: -3.6 +/- 0.1 for C/1995O1 and -3.3 +/- 0.3 for
29P/SW1. However, other characteristics of the dust environments are v
ery different, so that, in general, it is impossible to distinguish a
CO-driven comet from a typical water-driven one.