OBJECTIVE - To provide a context for the interpretation of lactic acid
osis risk among patients using metformin, we measured rates of lactic
acidosis in patients with type 2 diabetes before metformin was approve
d for use in the U.S. RESEARCH DESIGN AND METHODS - Using electronic d
atabases of hospital discharge diagnoses and laboratory results mainta
ined by a large, nonprofit health maintenance organization (HMO), we i
dentified possible lactic acidosis events in three geographically and
racially diverse populations with type 2 diabetes. We then reviewed ha
rd-copy clinical records to confirm and describe each event and determ
ine its likely cause(s). RESULTS - From >41,000 person-years of experi
ence, we found four confirmed, three possible, and three borderline ca
ses of lactic acidosis. In each case, we identified at least one sever
e medical condition that could have caused the acidosis. The annual co
nfirmed event rate is similar to published rates of metformin-associat
ed lactic acidosis. CONCLUSIONS - Lactic acidosis occurs regularly, al
though infrequently, among persons with type 2 diabetes, at rates simi
lar to its occurrence among metformin users. The medical conditions wi
th which both metformin-associated and naturally occurring lactic acid
osis co-occur are also its potential causes. The observed association
between metformin and lactic acidosis may be coincidental rather than
causal. This possibility merits further study.