Cv. Guidotti et Fp. Sassi, PETROGENETIC SIGNIFICANCE OF NA-K WHITE MICA MINERALOGY - RECENT ADVANCES FOR METAMORPHIC ROCKS, European journal of mineralogy, 10(5), 1998, pp. 815-854
In the last ten years much new work has been done on the petrogenetic
significance of the Na-K white micas in metamorphic rock, both by the
authors, and by numerous others. This paper reviews these new results.
Special emphasis is given to the new advances on the Pg-Ms mineralogy
and phase relations which the authors perceive as having direct petro
genetic significance for understanding metamorphic rocks. Several aspe
cts of these micas are considered in different sections: (1) Compositi
onal space is discussed in terms of deviations from end member Ms and
Pg formulas, as: (i) Ms-Pg substitution; (ii) celadonite substitutions
; (iii) a hypothetical ''ferrimuscovite'' substitution; (iv) margarite
substitution; (v) deficiency in the XII site; (vi) occurrence of othe
r minor or trace components which may have a petrological significance
. (2) Analytical problems are discussed in terms of instrumental diffi
culties and recognition of poor quality analyses. (3) Some aspects of
the Na-K mica crystal chemistry are briefly considered: (i) effects of
compositional variation on cell dimensions; (ii) explanations for the
observed relationships; (iii) chemical implications for the solid sol
ution behavior; (iv) crystal chemical effects of the minor and trace s
ubstitutions; (v) new crystal structure refinement work. (4) With rega
rds to polytypism, 2M(1) is the most common polytype in these micas, b
eing typical of: (i) phengite-poor Ms over their whole P-T stability f
ield; (ii) phengite-rich Ms formed at whatever T under low to medium P
. 3T is less common, and typical of phengites from high P/T terrains.
A high P/T ratio seems to be the necessary condition for the 3T stacki
ng, rather than the phengitic composition. (5) Petrological factors ar
e considered which demonstrate how rock bulk composition controls mica
chemistry. (6) The effect of the rock oxidation state on muscovite an
d paragonite chemistry is discussed: (i) redox state as indicated by t
he opaque minerals present is, for a given P-T-aAl(2)O(3), the main co
ntrol on the extent to which Al-VI is replaced by Fe3+; and (ii) for a
given P-T redox state, aAl(2)O(3) (as indicated by the silicate miner
al assemblage) is the prime control on the extent of this replacement.
Ignoring Fe3+ in Ms causes significant underestimations of the Mg/Fe2
+ ratio in Ms, with serious consequences for cation exchange geothermo
barometry. (7,8) Geothermometry and geobarometry involving Ms and Pg a
re extensively discussed, with regards to petrologic rationale plus li
mits of validity; e.g. it is shown that the Ms-Pg geothermometer canno
t be used at P > 0.8 GP. (9) A petrogenetic grid involving key AKNa re
actions including Ms and/or Pg is discussed in order to show the petro
logic effects of non-AKNa components substituting into the micas. (10)
Rock-fluid interaction during metamorphism is discussed in order to s
how how the stability and chemistry of Na-K micas is also affected by
the changing chemistry of the fluid phase.