Jd. Happell et al., STABLE ISOTOPES AS TRACERS OF METHANE DYNAMICS IN EVERGLADES MARSHES WITH AND WITHOUT ACTIVE POPULATIONS OF METHANE-OXIDIZING BACTERIA, JOURNAL OF GEOPHYSICAL RESEARCH-ATMOSPHERES, 98(D8), 1993, pp. 14771-14782
Methane flux from Cladium jamaicense varied from 0.2 to 15 mmol m-2 d-
1 and was 1.4 to 26 (avg = 5.64 +/- 8.57, n = 13, error is +/- 1 stand
ard deviation throughout) times greater than the flux from the flood w
ater. The lack of diurnal variations in both the rate of CH4 emission
and its stable carbon isotopic composition suggests that CH4 flux from
Cladium was independent of stomatal aperture and that gases were tran
sported through the plant mainly via passive diffusion and/or effusion
as opposed to active pressurized ventilation. Rhizospheric CH4 oxidat
ion did not cause C-13-enriched CH4 to be emitted to the atmosphere by
Cladium jamaicense. Previous workers have shown that Everglades soil
types differ in that CH4 oxidizing bacteria are active in peat soils a
nd inactive in marl soils (King et al., 1990; Gerard, 1992), however a
comparison of the stable isotopic composition of emitted and sediment
ary CH4 from Cladium marshes within marl and peat soils provided no ev
idence that rhizospheric CH4 oxidizing bacteria were consuming signifi
cant quantities of CH4 in situ within peat soils. Either CH4 oxidation
in the rhizosphere was insignificant due to O2 limitation or it occur
red quantitatively in discrete zones within the sediment, thereby impa
rting no isotopic signal to sedimentary CH4. Linear relationships betw
een CH4 flux and live aboveground Cladium biomass in marl and peat soi
ls were identical and offered no evidence for rhizospheric CH4 oxidati
on in peat soils. In Contrast core incubation experiments indicated th
at CH4 oxidizing bacteria at the sediment-water interface in peat soil
s intercepted and oxidized from 41 to 93 % (avg = 71 +/- 20 %, n = 9)
of the CH4 diffusing from the sediments toward the overlying flood wat
er. Furthermore, we were able to detect sediment-water interface oxida
tion with stable isotopes as CH4 emitted from the flood water (deltaC-
13 = 57.3 +/- 3.6 parts per thousand, n = 5) after plants were clipped
below the water surface was enriched in C-13 by over 10 parts per tho
usand relative to CH4 emitted from vegetated plots (deltaC-13 = -68.1
+/- 2.5 parts per thousand n = 10). Methane within flood water (before
clipping) at peat sites was also C-13 enriched (deltaC-13 = -57.6 +/-
4.3 parts per thousand, n = 7). Lowering of the water table below the
sediment surface caused an Everglades sawgrass marsh to shift from CH
4 emission to the consumption of atmospheric CH4 at a rate of 55 +/- 4
1 mumol m-2d-1.