Prime starch was extracted from soft and hard wheat flours and ball-mi
lled to produce 100% damaged starch. Small amounts of the ball-milled
starch or a pregelatinized starch were added to sugar-snap cookie form
ulations. Other cookie doughs were produced from prime starch only (no
flour) with small amounts of the ball-milled starch added. Starch dam
ages of the resulting substituted soft and hard wheat flours and soft
and hard wheat prime starches were determined and compared to diameter
s of sugar-snap cookies produced from the control and treatments. Soft
wheat flour and starches produced larger diameter cookies than their
hard wheat counterpart at all levels of damaged starch. Both sources o
f damaged starch (ball-milled or pregelatinized starch) had similar ef
fects on cookie diameter. Cookies produced from all starch (no flour)
were similar to their respective flour controls at approximate to 8% d
amaged starch. To produce the same size cookie as that produced by sof
t wheat flour and starch, hard wheat flour and starch cookie formulati
ons required less damaged starch and had lower alkaline water retentio
n than did the soft wheat flour and starch cookie formulations. Other
flours were treated with chlorine gas to pH 4.8. Pregelatinized starch
(approximate to 5%) was required to reduce the cookie diameter as muc
h as chlorine treatment did. Results suggest unique quality difference
s between soft and hard wheat starch as they function in sugar-snap co
okie baking. The functional results of those differences are not adequ
ately quantified by the estimation of damaged starch level.