Enroth-Cugell and Robson (1966) first proposed a classification of ret
inal ganglion cells into X cells, which exhibit approximate linear spa
tial summation and largely sustained responses, and Y cells, which exh
ibit nonlinearities and transient responses. Gaudiano (1992a, 1992b, 1
994) has suggested that the dominant characteristics of both X and Y c
ells can be simulated with a single model simply by changing receptive
field profiles to match those of the anatomical counterparts of X and
Y cells. He also proposed that a significant component of the spatial
nonlinearities observed in Y (and sometimes X) cells can result from
photoreceptor nonlinearities coupled with push-pull bipolar connection
s. Specifically, an asymmetry was predicted in the ganglion cell respo
nse to rectangular gratings presented at different locations in the re
ceptive field under two conditions: introduction/withdrawal (on-off) o
r contrast reversal. When measuring the response to these patterns as
a function of spatial phase, the standard difference-of-Gaussians mode
l predicts symmetrical responses about the receptive field center, whi
le the push-pull model predicts slight but significant asymmetry in th
e on-off case only. To test this hypothesis, we have recorded ganglion
cell responses from the optic tract fibers of anesthetized cat. The m
ean and standard deviations of responses to on-off and contrast-revers
ed patterns were compared. We found that all but one of the cells that
yielded statistically significant data confirmed the hypothesis. Thes
e results largely support the theoretical prediction.