The steady-state flow generated by a rotating bottom in a closed cylin
drical container and the resulting vortex breakdown bubbles have been
studied experimentally. By comparing the flow inside two different con
tainer geometries, one with a rigid cover and the other with a free su
rface, we examined the way in which the formation and structure of the
breakdown bubbles depend on the surrounding flow. Details of the flow
were visualized by means of the electrolytic precipitation technique,
whereas a particle tracking technique was used to characterize the wh
ole flow field. We found that the breakdown bubbles inside the contain
er flow are in many ways similar to those in vortex tubes. First, the
bubbles are open with in- and outflow and second, their structure is,
like in the case of vortex breakdown in pipe flows, highly axisymmetri
c on the upstream side of the bubble and asymmetric on their rear side
. However, and surprisingly, we observed bubbles which are open and st
ationary at the same time. This shows that open breakdown bubbles are
not necessarily the result of periodic oscillations of the recirculati
on zone. The asymmetry of the flow structure is found to be related to
the existence of asymmetric flow separations on the container wall. I
f the angular velocity of the rotating bottom is increased the evoluti
on of the breakdown bubbles is different in both configurations: in th
e rigid cover case the breakdown bubbles disappear but persist in the
free surface case.