Cj. Waterfield et al., ETHIONINE TOXICITY IN-VITRO - THE CORRELATION OF DATA FROM RAT HEPATOCYTE SUSPENSIONS AND MONOLAYERS WITH IN-VIVO OBSERVATIONS, Archives of toxicology, 72(9), 1998, pp. 588-596
The hepato-steatogenic compound ethionine has been used to investigate
the correlations between in vivo and in vitro toxicity data. The aim
was to find a suitable model of toxicity in hepatocyle suspensions or
monolayers in vitro, which could predict the known toxicity of ethioni
ne in vivo and which could be implemented in screening compounds of un
known toxicity. Thus a variety of markers of cytotoxicity, metabolic c
ompetence and liver-specific functions were investigated in rat hepato
cyte suspensions and monolayers and compared with in vivo data in the
rat. The following markers were measured in the appropriate system: (1
) Neutral red uptake; 3-(4,5 dimethyl)thiazol-2-yl,-2.5-diphenyl tetra
zolium bromide (MTT) reduction; lactate dehydrogenase (LDH), aspartate
aminotransferase (AST) and alanine aminotransferase (ALT) leakage (cy
totoxicity). (2) ATP levels: protein synthesis and glutathione (GSH) l
evels (metabolic competence). (3) Urea and triglyceride synthesis and
beta-oxidation (liver specific functions). Ethionine (0-30 mM) did not
affect the markers of direct cytotoxicity, except neutral red uptake,
which was reduced by 18 and 30 mM ethionine after 20 h in culture. AT
P and GSH depletion occurred in hepatocyte suspensions at the highest
centrations of ethionine (20 and 30 mM) after 1 h. In monolayers. GSH
levels were reduced after 4 h, but not 20 h. Urea synthesis was increa
sed in hepatocyte suspensions from I to 3 h by 10-30 mM ethionine and
reduced after 20 h in cultured hepatocytes (18-30 mM). Protein synthes
is was reduced and beta-oxidation was increased in ethionine-treated h
epatocyte suspensions. Unfortunately, there was no measurable effect o
n triglyceride accumulation within cells (the major biochemical change
in vivo) in either system. Ethionine treated hepatocytes in suspensio
n showed the same rate of triglyceride synthesis and transportation ou
t of cells as control cells. Thus, hepatocyte suspensions were able to
mimic the early biochemical effects of ethionine in vivo (ATP and GSH
depletion, inhibition of protein synthesis) and some effects on urea
synthesis, but monolayer cultures appeared to be less sensitive to the
toxicity of ethionine. However, neither in vitro system was able to m
odel the effects of ethionine on the accumulation of triglycerides in
vivo.