INCREASED CARDIOPULMONARY DISEASE RISK IN A COMMUNITY-BASED SAMPLE WITH CHEMICAL ODOR INTOLERANCE - IMPLICATIONS FOR WOMENS HEALTH AND HEALTH-CARE UTILIZATION
Cm. Baldwin et Ir. Bell, INCREASED CARDIOPULMONARY DISEASE RISK IN A COMMUNITY-BASED SAMPLE WITH CHEMICAL ODOR INTOLERANCE - IMPLICATIONS FOR WOMENS HEALTH AND HEALTH-CARE UTILIZATION, Archives of environmental health, 53(5), 1998, pp. 347-353
Chemical intolerance, or reported illness from odors of common environ
mental chemicals (e.g., car exhaust, pesticides), is emerging as an im
portant environmental and public health-care issue. Epidemiologic meth
ods provide relevant heuristic devices for studies of complex disorder
s, such as chemical intolerance. The authors examined personal and rep
orted parental cardiopulmonary disease prevalence rates in a community
sample of chemically intolerant and control individuals. A county gov
ernment (Tucson, Arizona) employee and kin subset (N = 181; 113 househ
olds) completed standard health questionnaires. investigators determin
ed chemical intolerance (n = 41/181) from self-reports of individuals
who felt ''moderately'' to ''severely'' ill from exposure to at least
three of five chemicals (i.e., car exhaust, pesticides, paint, new car
pet, and perfume) on a Chemical Odor Intolerance Index. The authors ch
ose the control group (n = 57/181) on the basis of self-reports of ''n
ever'' feeling ill on the Chemical Odor Intolerance Index. The chemica
lly intolerant group, which primarily comprised women (78% versus 51%
of controls, p < .05), was significantly more likely to report-and to
have sought-medical attention for heart problems, bronchitis, asthma,
and pneumonia. Reports of heart problems in the chemically intolerant
index cases and the occurrence of heart disease in both of their paren
ts were significant (Fisher's p < .05). The chemically intolerant indi
viduals were also significantly more likely to report maternal histori
es of chest problems (e,g., inhalant allergens, tuberculosis) than con
trols. The findings of the study suggested that the chemically intoler
ant individuals (a preponderance of whom were women [sex-related risk]
) were move likely to have (a) reported cardiopulmonary problems (i.e.
, greater health risk); (b) actively sought medical care for these pro
blems (i.e., increased medical utilization); and (c) reported more par
ental illnesses-particularly heart disease, asthma, and diabetes (i.e.
, genetic risk). Additional community-based studies of chemical intole
rance are needed.