Background The cause of irritable bowel syndrome (IBS) is unknown. It
may follow gastroenteritis and be associated with an abnormal gut flor
a and with food intolerance. Our study was designed to assess whether
these factors were associated with colonic malfermentation. Methods We
carried out a crossover controlled trial of a standard diet and an ex
clusion diet matched for macronutrients in six female IBS patients and
six female controls. During the final 72 h on each diet, faecal excre
tion of fat, nitrogen, starch, and non-starch polysaccharide NSP was m
easured, and total excretion of hydrogen and methane collected over 24
h in a purpose-built 1.4 m(3) whole-body calorimeter. Breath hydrogen
and methane excretion were then measured for 3 h after 20 g oral lact
ulose. Findings The maximum rate of gas excretion was significantly gr
eater in patients than in controls (2.4 mL/min IQR 1.7-2.6 vs 0.6, 0.4
-1.1). Although total gas production in patients was not greater than
in controls (median 527 mL/24 h IQR 387-660 vs 412, 234-507), hydrogen
production was higher (332, 318-478 vs 162, 126-217, p=0.009). In pat
ients, the exclusion diet reduced symptoms and produced a fall in maxi
mum gas excretion (0.5 mL/min IQR 0.3-0.7). After lactulose, breath hy
drogen was greater on the standard than on the exclusion diet. Interpr
etation Colonic-gas production, particularly of hydrogen, is greater i
n patients with IBS than in controls, and both symptoms and gas produc
tion are reduced by an exclusion diet. This reduction may be associate
d with alterations in the activity of hydrogen-consuming bacteria. Fer
mentation may be an important factor in the pathogenesis of IBS.