R. Franz et F. Welle, Analytical screening and development of an analytical method for quality assurance checking of market usual PET flakes, DEUT LEBENS, 95(3), 1999, pp. 94-100
Due to the increasing market share of soft drink bottles made from poly(eth
ylene terephthalate) (PET), the recycling of PET for new food packaging app
lications is gaining more and more economic interest. However, in order to
meet the challenging food regulatory requirements, a rapid and efficient an
alytical quality assurance is necessary to recognize any foreign and unwant
ed compounds in the PET material. Moreover it is required to have knowledge
about real life contaminants concentrations in market PET recyclates in or
der to allow an assessment whether such PET recyclates can be further proce
ssed to obtain purified recyclate products of virgin material like quality
suitable for direct food contact packaging applications.
The aim of this study was to determine the current status quo of market-usu
al PET flakes with respect to their migration relevant foreign compound pot
ential. The establishment of an analytical method suitable for quality assu
rance checking was another aim. For this purpose approx. 150 PET samples or
iginating from 14 European PET recyclers and recyclate converters have been
investigated, from each of the PET samples an analytical GC fingerprint wa
s made which was qualitatively evaluated, In addition, acetaldehyde and lim
onene were specifically quantified. As a result, it was shown that the inve
stigated "post-consumer" PET samples as obtained from conventional recyclin
g processes are not as such already suitable for direct food contact. The t
hreshold concentration in the PET material as proposed by US-FDA was found
to be exceeded in numerous cases for several substances. On the other hand,
these substances were identified in the major cases to be aroma constituen
ts of soft drinks of no toxicological concern. Limonene, as an example, was
found to occur in a concentration range from 1.5 to 11 ppm in the PET flak
es. The investigated PET samples were of good and very homogenous quality,
thus being promising candidate materials for inclusion in a sandwich struct
ure behind a functional barrier. In any case, however, the observed materia
l qualities can serve or be used as input material for further purification
processes, Given sufficient cleansing efficiency of such a process, in thi
s way "post-consumer" PET recyclate qualities can be obtained which should
be suitable for new direct food contact packaging applications. The same ho
lds true and even more clearly for the investigated industrial scrab sample
s which are almost comparable to virgin PET quality. The acetaldehyde conce
ntrations were, however, found to be significantly higher in scrab samples.
In opposite, PET samples obtained from the German DSD recollection system
turned out as not suitable for food packaging. The reasons can be seen in t
he low polymer type purity and the relatively high fractions of foreign com
pounds resulting from former technical bottle contents,
Concerning the analytical methodology the established headspace GC procedur
e has been proven to be the most suitable approach to solve the problem. Th
e low limits of detection achieved with this methodology do allow an evalua
tion and certification of PET recyclates for this highly challenging and se
nsitive re-application in food packaging.