Chlorine atom initiated oxidation of chlorinated ethenes: Results for 1,1-dichloroethene (H2C=CCl2), 1,2-dichloroethene (HClC=CClH), trichloroethene (HClC=CCl2), and tetrachloroethene (Cl2C=CCl2)
As. Hasson et Iwm. Smith, Chlorine atom initiated oxidation of chlorinated ethenes: Results for 1,1-dichloroethene (H2C=CCl2), 1,2-dichloroethene (HClC=CClH), trichloroethene (HClC=CCl2), and tetrachloroethene (Cl2C=CCl2), J PHYS CH A, 103(13), 1999, pp. 2031-2043
Experiments have been carried out on the oxidation of the four chlorinated
ethenes H2C=CCl2, HClC=CClH, HClC=CCl2, and Cl2C=CCl2. Reaction was initiat
ed by continuous photolysis of Cl-2, and product yields were measured using
Fourier transform infrared (FTIR) spectroscopy. In all cases, experiments
were performed at different concentrations of the chlorinated ethenes (down
to 3 x 10(13) molecule cm(-3)), Cl-2 and O-2. In the cases of H2C=CCl2 and
HClC=CCl2, the product yields were invariant with these changes, consisten
t with them being determined by competitive unimolecular dissociations of t
he chlorinated alkoxy radical; that is, H2ClCCCl2O (HCl2CCCl2O) (+M) --> H2
ClCCOCl (HCl2CCOCl) + Cl (+M) and H2ClCCCl2O (HCl2CCCl2O) (+M) --> COCl2 CH2Cl (CHCl2) (+M), and the subsequent formation of HCOCl and/or COCl2 from
CH2Cl and CHCl2. In the case of HCl2CCHClO formed from HClC=CClH, H atom a
bstraction by O-2 is competitive with CCl and CC bond cleavage, so the yiel
ds depended on the concentration of O-2. With C2Cl4, the only products obse
rved were CC3COCl and COCl2 consistent with competitive dissociations of pe
rchloroethyl radicals: CCl3CCl2O (+M) --> CCl3COCl + Cl (+M); CCl3CCl2O (+M
) --> COCl2 + CCl3 (+M). However, the relative yields of CCl3COCl and COCl2
were found to depend on the initial concentration of C2Cl4 which is incomp
atible with the simple, and generally accepted, mechanism. To investigate t
his unexpected result further, experiments were performed on pentachloroeth
ane (C2Cl5H). Again, the product yields depended on the initial concentrati
on of the chlorinated compound. In addition, product yields from C2Cl4 were
measured using two different rates of photolysis of Cl-2, at three tempera
tures, 298, 353, and 393 K, and in the presence of added NO and added HCl.
Although the experimental results could be modeled when bimolecular reactio
ns of perchlorinated methoxy and ethoxy radicals with C2Cl4 and HCl were in
cluded in the reaction mechanisms, the values of the rate constants which w
ere needed seem unrealistically large if the currently accepted rate for th
e unimolecular decomposition of CCl3CCl2O is correct. This observation on C
2Cl4 is important since it casts doubt on the current view of the oxidative
chemistry of this compound, which is released in significant amounts into
the atmosphere.